Re: [hatari-devel] LED with empty floppy drives

[Nicolas Pomarède <npomarede@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Le 09/06/2014 22:35, Vincent Rivière a écrit :
> On 05/05/2014 10:12, Nicolas Pomarède wrote:
> > > When determining if the light should stay on or turn off, you should
> > > precisely specify if you are talking about the drive LED or the keyboard
> > > LED.
> >
> > On my STE, both leds are switching on/off at the exact same time ; the
> > led
> > on the internal drive is not always visible, it's sometimes behind the
> > plastic case.
>
> It seems that different testers on real hardware did not see the same
> results.
> It is still unclear if the B: drive LED should remain on or off. In
> other words, if the new Hatari behavior is a bug or feature.
>
> Currently, when booting EmuTOS on Hatari, the B: LED stays turned on
> when the desktop is idle, that's ugly.
> I would like to know which of Hatari or EmuTOS needs to be fixed.

On my STF and my STE with 2 drives, if I boot without any disk, when GEM 
desktop appears, drive A led is ON and drive B led is OFF.

With Hatari and TOS 1.04 or 1.62, I get the exact same behaviour as my 
STF/STE : drive A remains ON and drive B if OFF.

I just booted Hatari with emutos, and at the end when desktop appears, 
drive A led is OFF and drive B is ON. So this is the opposite of what we 
see under real STF/STE or Hatari with Atari's TOS.

I can't say if Hatari is wrong about some routines used by Emutos, but 
at least it's 100 %d identical to real ST with real TOS.

Nicolas