| Re: [tablatures] Bends: tests for appearance of pointed slurs |
[ Thread Index |
Date Index
| More lilynet.net/tablatures Archives
]
- To: David Stocker <dstocker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: Re: [tablatures] Bends: tests for appearance of pointed slurs
- From: Marc Hohl <marc@xxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 01 Jan 2010 16:52:20 +0100
- Cc: tablatures@xxxxxxxxxxx
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha1; c=relaxed/relaxed; t=1262361142; l=1764; s=domk; d=hohlart.de; h=Content-Transfer-Encoding:Content-Type:In-Reply-To:References: Subject:CC:To:MIME-Version:From:Date:X-RZG-CLASS-ID:X-RZG-AUTH; bh=ef/jJxIkX/G+BGyXk8YT4IDe02k=; b=T4lxq/VP38OCezxA3HZ1VsO8ub9Meg1Bj1fdr9fBU/awnJnPQ7yDmDDnq+ngW4IESiF t/VRxiviOOYkJgMbOymLdCJs2FKf1jqACWiHnZ6AIHtWGLzrj9JTPk/GLUqTuKPhXPi/3 OAWtKEOArLxoKN+LM+/pBaS7FG+1D+m1XnE=
David Stocker schrieb:
These are excellent results! Great work.
I think the third configuration yields the best appearance.
I only have a few comments:
1. In a bend and release combination, it would be nice if the
right-most edge of the "bend-up" line and the left-most edge of
the "release-down" line were separated by about 0.25 staff spaces.
Oh, and I tried hard to make these lines connect - but this can be
changed easily.
2. In Measure 13, the bend line that corresponds to the tie in the
note-staff (during the \holdBend) should be a dashed line.
Yes, I know; there's is a comment in bend.ly pointing this out. The main
purpose for this test
was the pointed slur in the normal staves - the tablature stuff is a
separate issue.
These results are already as good as or better than the defaults in
Sibelius and Finale.
Wow - thanks!
I have collected some ideas and informations for the final conception,
so I plan to start soon
with a proper implementation; this means new engravers and stuff.
Before starting to code, I think I will release a feature list and hope
to get a lot of response from
you tablature guys.
One question especially to David due to his engraving knowledge:
assume the following situation: I play an a on the tenth fret on the b
string
and do a three semitone bend to the c. Then I release partly to the b
and afterwards
fully down to the a again. How do I indicate this? The first part is easy: a
bendUp arrow with "1 1/2" over the arrow with a bigger amount in y direction
to gain enough space in vertical direction for two adjacent release arrows.
Should the "1" for the bent b be placed somewhere? If yes,where?
Greetings and best wishes for 2010,
Marc